Good brewing pumps are a must to have a quality brew. That’s why brewing pumps have become very popular in home brewing systems. But which pump to choose and on what basis?
So, which one to choose when it comes to chugger pump vs march?
The materials of Chugger and March are the same but the head is not. Both have a heat tolerance of Upto 250° F. Chugger has a bigger inlet of 3/4″ than the March pump. March has a little higher flow rate while Chugger has a higher max head.
Too much information to take in? If not, then head on to our detailed comparison between these two pumps.
So let’s get started!
Chugger Vs March: A Brief Comparision
The functionality is pretty similar. Like blichmann riptide both are not self-priming pumps. Both of them like any brewers have an outlet to control the flow. And input for assisting the primming process of the pump.
You may be wondering how to prime brewing pump. But it’s not that hard. You can find it online and its quite similar to priming a riptide pump. You may also find it in chugger pump setup manual.
Their advantages and disadvantages are also quite the same. However, there are still some small differences you might want to know about. But the differences are not as big as riptide vs chugger. Also, blichmann riptide problems are also easily fixable.
Riptide pump is among the best homebrew pump in the market. Check out any riptide pump review for a better understanding.
Both of these pumps are very good in quality. Problems like clogged keg are very unlikely to happen to these pumps.
So, let’s check out a brief comparison between these two pumps.
|Parameters||Chugger Pump||March Pump|
|Material||Stainless Steel||Stainless Steel, plastic|
|Heat Tolerance||Upto 250° F||Upto 250° F|
|Inlet and Outlet||3/4″ and 1/2″||1/2″ and 1/2″|
|Maximum Flow Rate||7.2 GPM||7.5 GPM|
|Max Head||18.6 ft||12.1 ft|
|Price Range||Within $80-160||Within $180-400|
This brief comparison should give you an idea about the differences between these two pumps. In case you’re interested to know more, we have a whole guide for you. Keep reading.
Or if you want a recommendation right now, skip to our final verdict section.
As we have seen already, both of these pumps are packed with similar specifications. They are quite equal in every sector except a few. Let’s head on to the details.
The Chugger pump and the March pump both have a body made of stainless steel. They are good quality stainless steel offering high-temperature brewing. But there is a twist.
In case of Chugger pump, the head of the brewer made of stainless steel. Whereas, the head of the March pump is made of plastic. This is something that may make anyone choose Chugger over March.
But you can still replace the head of the March pump. Or you can order the version with stainless steelhead. In that case, it will cost a little more than $180.
Since the Chugger and March pumps are identical you can use Chugger’s head in March.
So clearly the Chugger pump takes the cake here.
Winner: Chugger Pump
Finding it difficult to get hold of quality Chugger pumps? Pick your favorite from our recommendations!
The Chugger pump and the March pump both can withstand heat up to 250° F. So in this case both of the pumps are quite equal.
But as we have talked about the plastic head of the March pump. Many people can be uncomfortable using it at high temperatures.
But it definitely is a draw in terms of heat tolerance.
Inlet and Outlet
The size of the outlet and inlet can be a significant factor in terms of convenience. The March pump has a half-inch size of both outlet and inlet. Whereas the Chugger pump has a bigger inlet of 3/4″ and a similar outlet of 1/2″.
The difference is almost like the difference in 12 oz and 16 oz beer. It’s negligible.
Still, the Chugger pump is definitely ahead in this. But You can use a chugger pumps head in March pump. And many of the users have bought a Chugger head for their March pump.
Winner: Chugger Pump.
Maximum Flow Rate
The March pump has a flow rate of 7.2 GPM. On the other hand, the Chugger pump has 7 GPM. Even though the difference is significant it still exists. The motor of the March pump is also argued as a better quality motor and less noisy.
So the winner is quite clear here.
Winner: March Pump
Willing to spend some extra bucks to get hold on March Pumps? Why not try out this following March pumps that we tested out ourselves? We highly recommend trying them out:
The max head limit is the amount of backpressure a pump can withstand. In the Chugger pump the max head of 18.6 ft.
On the other hand, the March pump has a max head of 12.1 ft. This means the Chugger pump can handle higher back pressure from the brewing kettles.
So clearly the winner is Chugger here.
Winner: Chugger Pump
The March pump is the more expensive one as the brand itself is quite reputed. The Chugger pump costs less and that’s one of the main reasons why it’s attractive.
The pump is originally manufactured in the USA. It has a good reputation as a company for making brewing pumps.
Wondering then what is a chugger pump? Many consider Chugger as a copycat version of the March pump. It’s also true that Chugger has not disappointed many users. But the March pump is more established as a brand.
These are the reasons why the March pump and Chugger pump has a price difference.
The Chugger pump costs around $150-160 whereas the March pump costs around $180-200. The March pump can cost a bit more if you order the version with stainless steelhead.
You can also check out some best brewing pumps in recent times for your home. And also learn the guide for brewery pump selection.
So chugger pump vs march pump comes down to your preference. Both of the pumps are very similar in terms of their advantages and disadvantages. So here’s our recommendation.
The March pump is a more reputed and established brand for brewing pumps. If the specifications match your needs. And if the price is not a concern for you then the March pump is a good choice. You may also get a stainless steel head paying a little more.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for a cheaper alternative then Chugger is a good choice. The Chugger pump also gives you additional benefits like max head and better head material. But it’s still a new brand so if you want to take the risk then you sure can.
So here’s our final verdict in short:
|Product||How’s it useful?||Available now|
|March Pump||Reputed brand, better motor, better flow rate||Available only at $180-200|
|Chugger Pump||Less expensive, Stainless steel head||Available only at $150-160|
What is self-priming?
The priming process involves eliminating air from both the pump and the line of suction. This method involves filling the pump with the substance to be pushed. This causes all air, gas, or vapor trapped in the pump’s passageways to escape. Priming can be done by hand or by machine.
Why is priming needed?
Priming lessens the threat of pump degradation at startup by preventing the impeller from becoming gas-bound. And as a result unable to pump the necessary liquid. Pumps should first be primed, which requires the removal of air or gases. The pump won’t work properly if it isn’t entirely filled.
What’s the weight of both the pumps?
Both of the pumps are very close in terms of weight. The Chugger pump is a little lighter in weight. The March pump weighs around 6 lbs whereas the Chugger pump weighs around 5.5 lbs. Even though half a pound might seem insignificant most of the time. But sometimes that half pound can be important.
That will wrap it all for today. We hope we could give you a good idea about the chugger pump vs march.
Whichever pump you choose, use them following the instruction manual. Otherwise, you may damage the pump.
Good luck with your Brewing experience!