Carafoam Vs Carahell: Which One Should You Go For?

You’re planning to get into brewing. But you’re confused about what base malt to use. Because there are a lot of options out there.

You narrow it down to carafoam and carahill from weyermann. But carafoam vs carahill, which one should you choose?

Carafoam and carahill produce two very different results. Carafoam has a lighter color with better body and head retention. And carahill is darker toned and has a high malty taste. Using carafoam is a bit easier as it doesn’t require mash and has an easier recipe.

There you go! But I’m sure you want to know about this in a detailed manner. And we have prepared an article just for that.

So follow along with our detailed article to find out more!

A Brief Comparison 

Brewing on your own is not an easy task. It takes lots of consideration and care before even starting to brew. Because every decision has a direct impact on your outcome.

The ingredients you use, the time you give it, malted or unmalted barley, all of these matter. The slightest change will change how your beer will taste.

Choosing a base malt is perhaps the most important factor of them all. The main taste and color depends on the base malt you choose.

You have a lot of options in this category. From the company weyermann carahell and carafoam malts are available. These two are very different from each other. And they will give you different results when you use them.

So let’s take a quick look at the main differences between them:

FactorCarafoamCarahell
SRM 111
Grain Bill Percentage5%50%
Mash RequirementNoYes

From the quick comparison it gets pretty clear. Carafoam and carahell are two pretty different candidates if you want to talk about base malt.

Now, let’s go down and discuss further how they actually differ. We will talk about their effect in the mix, and also various carafoam and carahell substitute.

Detailed Comparison

If you’re considering using carahell malt or carafoam as your base malt then you must think carefully. Because they are totally different from each other and yield totally different results.

The effect they have on the beer is different and they bring forth different flavors. So let’s discuss all about them in detail so that you can make a wise choice.

Standard Reference Method or SRM

Standard reference system or SRM is a metric to measure color of beer. And using different base malts brings out different colors.

Colors in beer have a lot of value. The color can range from golden yellow to straw yellow to dark brown. And SRM is a metric that uses numbers to refer to a certain color.

This SRM heavily depends on the base malt that you use. So choosing either carafoam or carahell malt will give you different colors in the end.

Carafoam malt has an SRM of 1, which means it brings out the lightest color possible. It looks sort of golden yellowish in color.

Source: Brulosophy

On the other hand, if carahell is used as base malt then the color is much darker. As carahell has an SRM of 11.

Source: hobbyhomebrew

So if you have a specific color for your finished brew in mind, then you have to consider what you’re using. If you want a light color then carafoam will do the job. And for a darker tone, carahell is the way to go.

Grain Bill Percentage

Grain bill is actually the basic overview of the ingredients that you’re going to use in your brew.

You can make various grain bills like you prepare a mixture of ingredients. You can say that this is the carafoam or carahell malt recipe.

You can use different percentages of various malts and other ingredients. And different grain bills will give you different results in terms of taste, flavor, and color.

In a grain bill, carafoam can be used for a maximum of only 5% of the whole batch. This means if you want to make a brew that has carafoam as the base malt, you could do it with a very small amount.

But if you want to use carahell malt, then the number goes significantly up. Carafoam, when used as the base malt, takes up 50% of the total grain bill.

So, it’s pretty clear that you have to use a lot less base malt to bring out the characteristics of carafoam malt with respect to carahell. So if you want to work with a lesser amount of malts then carafoam is what you want.

Mash Needed Or Not

Mashing is the process of soaking your malt in water. And making a porridge-like mixture. Which helps it to bring out the necessary enzymes.

While using carafoam malt, making a mash isn’t required. It can be used to brew instantly. That saves time and also water.

But if you want to use carahell malt then a mash is absolutely necessary. So you’ll have to invest that time and resources in there. Carahell is used to brew ales around the world.

The differences between carahell and carafoam aren’t subtle at all. So the choice you make depends entirely on the result that you want to have.

But if you must pick between any two, then what should you do? Let’s get down to our final verdict section and see.

Final Verdict

Brewing is not only mixing and matching a bunch of things. You need a proper goal and a fixed plan to achieve your desired results.

Color, taste, head retention, body, maltiness everything depends on the ingredients you choose.

Carahell malt vs carafoam shows us exactly how much effect this difference has.

As we can see, using carafoam malt greatly improves body and head retention. This is the addition of body to beer. It gives you a light color and it also needs to be used just a small percentage.

But if you choose to use a carahell malt recipe, then it mainly deepens the color of the brew. And as it is used for nearly 50% of the total grain bill,  the maltiness of the drink is also increased.

So the choice mainly depends on what effect you want in your beer. But if you want our opinion, the carafoam one just takes less time and it gives you a much nicer-looking beer.

Here’s our recommendation for the finest Carafoam malts out there.

Also, you need fewer resources than carahell based beers. So if you’re trying to make a quick brew, go for carafoam. But if a malty deep tones drink is your choice, then carahell is the way to go!

FAQs

Is Carapils The Same As Carafoam?

Yes,  carapils are the same as carafoame. Both of them are dextrin malts. And they are both produced by malted barley. So if you don’t have any carafoam available near you, then you can definitely use carapils as a substitute to carafoam. Carapils is produced by the Briess malt and ingredient company.

Can You Brew With Unmalted Barley?

Yes, you can brew beer with unmalted barley. They are getting quite popular these days because of the economical value they hold. As they don’t need the additional water and time to germinate it saves quite a lot of resources. So many brewers prefer unmalted barley recently.

How Much Water Do You Need To Make A Mash?

To make a mash a ratio of 1.5-2 quarts of water per pound of grain is necessary. But some malts don’t need a mash at all. So having prior knowledge if your chosen malt needs a mash or not is necessary. Choosing a malt that doesn’t require mash, will save you some time and money.

Parting Words

Hopefully, you can now safely choose between carafoam vs carahell. Brewing takes a lot of practice and patience. So take it nice and slow and it’ll give you some satisfying results.

Have a good day and best of luck!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top